The Dangers of Electronic Communications

March 30, 2026

//

Joe Booth

originally written by Joe Booth on AmericanBar.org

I’m great at keeping secrets. It’s the people I tell them to who have the problem.

—Edward Snowden, at an open-mic night

We’ve all been there. You’re juggling court calls, kid drop-offs, and the daily flood of emails when you suddenly realize you just sent your client’s sensitive draft settlement proposal to opposing counsel. Or maybe you’re in a conference with one set of clients reviewing their matter on a large conference screen, when another client’s texts about hiding salacious information they feared would break the light of day pop up on the screen.

Those stomach-dropping moments aren’t just awkward—they’re ethical landmines. The American Bar Association (ABA) Model Rule 1.6 says we “shall make reasonable efforts to prevent the inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure” of client information. That duty is broad: it covers all information relating to the representation, no matter where it came from. And while the rule doesn’t demand that we wrap our files in titanium and guard them with attack dogs, it does expect us to take precautions proportionate to the sensitivity of the information, the risks of exposure, and the practical realities of law practice.

For family lawyers, the stakes are especially high. We handle finances, medical records, and intimate personal histories of our clients, their family, and other close associates. In the old days, that meant keeping the file room locked. Now, it means thinking about encryption, cloud storage settings, and who can see our computer screens. The tech tools that make our lives easier also make it easier for someone else to exploit.

This article is about how to live in that reality without losing your mind (or your license), starting with a closer look at what “reasonable efforts” mean when your client’s entire divorce file lives in your pocket and rests in the cloud.

Risks to Confidentiality: The Human Factor

She hit “reply all” by mistake. Instantly, she saw her soul leave her body and hover briefly above her desk with her bar number in hand.

This might sound funny—unless it’s your case, your client, and your reputation on the line.

Arguably, most breaches of confidentiality involve malicious actors or sophisticated hacks. More often, they’re the result of our own habits colliding with the speed and convenience of modern communication. Examples could be: A client text preview flashing across your big screen monitor from one client while working with another client; an unencrypted file attachment sent over public Wi-Fi from the airport lounge, when you had 5G cell coverage as easily available; or, a cloud storage link set to “Anyone with the link” instead of restricted access. None of these require high-tech wizardry to exploit—they just require a moment’s inattention.

The Illinois State Bar Association’s Professional Conduct Advisory Opinion No. 98-04 gives two real-world examples: in one, a lawyer accidentally faxed a confidential spreadsheet to opposing counsel; in another, an internal note about preserving a defamation claim slipped into a draft settlement agreement that was sent across the aisle. In both cases, the information was immediately used to the client’s disadvantage. The opinion underscores that while technology has changed the medium, the human factor remains the primary risk—and one wrong click can undo months of work and hours of relationship building with our client.

These moments are largely avoidable.

  • Build in a pause before hitting send, especially when attachments or sensitive topics are involved.
  • Turn off previews so client communications aren’t broadcast to anyone glancing at your phone or tablet.
  • Use two-factor authentication and password-protected links for file sharing.
  • And in your office, make confidentiality a shared responsibility, not an IT department afterthought.
  • The habit of blind copying your client on email communications that include external parties, like opposing counsel, keeps them from replying all and inadvertently spilling the beans.

Advising clients to get a unique email address dedicated to attorney/client communications prevents curious spouses and children from viewing emails on devices handed around the family over the years.

Consider a proportionate response to the case. In most cases representing our neighbors and their families, there is little to be learned that is not publicly known. As the client and their associates (for example a closely held company) increase in intrigue, so should the precautions. For the most sensitive, consider using unique file storage and communications. If you are a Dropbox user, for that client consider Teams, or other source that one with snoopy inclinations would not think to look.

The most common risks to confidentiality aren’t buried deep in the code. They are in the cloud over our heads, in our pockets, on our wrists, and at our fingertips.

Emerging Issues with AI Tools: The New Associate Who Never Sleeps

The admiral was so proud of the navy’s submarine sporting groundbreaking stealth technology he ordered a gold encrusted screen door.

Some lawyers treat AI like a bright new intern: eager, fast, and able to draft a 10-page memo in less time than it takes to find your glasses. The difference is, your intern doesn’t make a copy of every confidential fact you share and keep it in their head forever—at least, you hope not.

A few months ago, a colleague told me about an attorney who fed a messy set of client facts—names, dates, bank account numbers—into a free, public AI chatbot to “see what it thought” about the case. The AI produced a serviceable outline, but the problem wasn’t the answer—it was the fact that the attorney had just uploaded protected client information into a system that logs, stores, and might even use those inputs to train itself. That’s not “reasonable efforts” under Rule 1.6; that’s gift-wrapping your client’s privacy and dropping it on a stranger’s porch.

Here’s the plain-English version of the risk: most large public AI tools store the questions and answers you give them. Some “anonymize” the data, but anonymization can be undone if enough details pile up. Many also use past user inputs to improve their models—meaning your client’s secrets could become part of a giant statistical soup that other users indirectly taste. Even if no human at the company ever reads your prompt, the text is still sitting somewhere in a database you don’t control.

The good news? Just as you wouldn’t leave a titanium file cabinet full of divorce pleadings unlocked in the courthouse hallway, you don’t have to hand AI the keys to your client’s case. Some services, including certain GPT settings, allow you to turn off chat history and prevent training; others—like Google’s NotebookLM—keep uploaded material private by design. These tools are groundbreaking when used properly, for example this author used NotebookLM to upload the briefs for an appeal and the software created an audio like a podcast that discussed the client’s position and what points to hit home that the briefs hit hard on. That audio made preparing for oral arguments easier.

Specialized legal research platforms like Lexis, Westlaw, and Paxton AI lock down their systems contractually. Choosing those options, using encryption, and setting office-wide rules for AI use won’t make you bulletproof, but it will keep you from being the test case in the next ethics opinion.

Better Safe Than Sanctioned

Using the best tech without the proper cautions is like installing a fire sprinkler system, then storing gasoline next to the hot water tank.

By now, this probably feels less like an article and more like an intervention. The goal isn’t to make you paranoid—it’s to make “reasonable efforts” under Rule 1.6 second nature, even when you’re on your third cup of coffee and your inbox looks like a crime scene.

Rule 1.6(c) doesn’t ask us to eliminate all risk—it asks us to make reasonable efforts to prevent inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure. The comments spell out that “reasonable” is a sliding scale, factoring in the sensitivity of the information, the likelihood of disclosure if extra safeguards aren’t used, the cost and difficulty of those safeguards, and whether they interfere with representing the client. In practice, that means locking the front door even if you can’t build a moat. By taking concrete steps—whether that’s encryption, secure cloud settings, AI privacy controls, or regular staff training—we not only comply with our ethical duties, we also send a clear signal to clients: their information is handled with the care our profession demands, and with a level of diligence that justifies both their trust and the fees they pay for our counsel.

The basics aren’t glamorous, but they work:

  • Have a written firm policy for handling client data, from email encryption to AI use, so the rules aren’t living only in your head.
  • Train everyone—regularly. Don’t assume your staff knows the latest tricks (or traps) of cloud links, metadata, and secure file sharing.
  • Audit your systems the way you would a trust account. Periodic checkups keep you from discovering the gaps only after something falls through them.

Treat tech competence like legal competence—it’s not a “one and done” CLE topic. New platforms, devices, and threats pop up faster than the average family lawyer’s docket fills, and “I didn’t know” is not a defense the disciplinary board finds charming.

In the end, it’s about creating a practice where protecting client information is as reflexive as checking for typos in a pleading. The tools are there. The rules are relatively clear. The thing standing between you and a letter from disciplinary counsel is your decision to make security a daily habit.

After all, “better safe than sanctioned” may not be as catchy as “trust but verify,” but it will keep you sleeping better at night—and your bar number where it belongs.

Confidentiality Basics: Better Safe Than Sanctioned

Have a written policy.
Spell out firm rules for handling client data, from email encryption to AI use—don’t leave them living only in your head.

Train everyone—regularly.
Staff should know the latest dos and don’ts of cloud links, metadata, and secure file sharing.

Audit your systems.
Check your data security like you would a trust account—catch gaps before they become breaches.

Stay tech-competent.
Treat technology skills like legal skills—update constantly; “I didn’t know” is not a defense.

Secure communications.
Use encryption, restricted cloud access, and password-protected links for sensitive files.

Control the human factor.
Turn off lock-screen previews, blind copy clients when appropriate, and pause before hitting send.

Leave a Comment